Is Banning “Short-Selling” a Solution?

You may not have thought about it but short selling is a key component of modern efficient markets. Typically when you buy and sell things you buy them first hold them for a certain time (whether it is short or long term) and then sell it, (hopefully for more than you paid for it). But what if you feel the item is currently waaay too expensive? In that case, you can “sell short” in this case you borrow the item from a broker, sell it and when the price goes down buy it and return it to the broker. (Of course you have to pay the broker for any missed dividends and a “fee” for loaning it to you). But if the stock falls enough you can make a nice profit. According to Investopedia, “Short selling strengthens the market by exposing which companies’ stock prices are too high. In their search for overvalued firms, short sellers can discover accounting inconsistencies or other questionable practices before the market at large does.” So in effect, short sellers are registering a “negative vote” saying that they believe this stock is overpriced. But when bull-market hope turns to bear-market fear, short selling is often vilified as the cause of market crashes (rather than the fact that the short sellers were just observant enough to recognize overpriced stocks when they see them). This shift may be underway in Europe now. Whenever new technology enters a market it causes disruptions and eventually the old tech suffers as it is displaced by the new. Right now “FinTech” or Financial Technology is causing disruptions in Europe and as you would expect, the traditional financial services companies don’t like it. But the public becomes enamored with the new tech and drives up the price (often to extremely unreasonable levels). Once “irrational exuberance” takes over and the price of the stocks gets carried away then the short sellers come in with their “the emperor isn’t wearing any clothes”  and the price of the new tech crashes until it can build a firm base, show real profits and begin climbing again.  ~Tim McMahon, editor.